Matthew Mazzeo definitely got the name right for his dessert business. Ohmigod! Cookies will make you exclaim the phrase with just a single bite into one of their many cookies. The story of Ohmigod! began with a simple coffee cake which Matthew would bake with his dad. Tragically, Matthew’s father passed away when he was 11 years old. To keep the memory of his father alive, Matthew continued to bake their coffee cake. When he was 19 years old, he began to sell the coffee cake to local businesses, and with the help of his mom, Melody, Ohmigod! Desserts was founded.
The love and care that goes into each and every cookie, down to the signature, hand-tied black and white bow packaging, is what sets them apart from the competition. Ohmigod! Cookies, no matter which variety, tastes like it comes straight from the Mazzeo family’s kitchen. With mouth-watering varieties such as Night & Day black and white cookies, Raspberry Madness linzer tarts, and (my personal favorite) Pucker Up lemon cookies, you can’t go wrong! Ohmigod! Cookies can now be found at the Ramsey, Glen Rock, Wayne, and Morris Plains Vineyard Markets*. Next time you’re in, pick up a pack–trust me, you’ll be saying OHMIGOD! after the first bite!
*Selection varies by store.